CougarCorner

Re: 2016 BYU Coaching Staff

2017-11-21T10:53:07-06:00

No way Beck would come to BYU from UVA for anything less than OC. First BYU couldn't hope to match his pay, second, he can see that this entire staff will be fired in the next year or two while he's got job security where he is with an improving program. You don't get off the life boat and climb aboard the Titanic while it's sinking.

Statistics: Posted by hawkwing — Tue Nov 21, 2017 10:53 am

Re: 2016 BYU Coaching Staff

2017-11-21T10:41:47-06:00

I think Sitake and Detmer are safe for now. They'll get one more year to perform. I also don't think Sitake will let Tuiaki go. Is what it is. BUT, I'd like to see Kaufusi move back to dline - which would move Tuiaki back to linebackers.

And, isn't the 2018 season where the NCAA will allow an additional coach? A couple of realistic moves:

- Add Jason Beck as quarterbacks coach. He and Mangum had a great rapport and productive results in 2015. Not sure BYU will offer enough to lure him away from Virginia, but I'd try. This move helps to support Detmer and the offense, where we need it most.

- Let go of Cahoon and bring in Roderick as receivers coach. He's a proven P5 receivers coach and a good recruiter. And, he's available.

Nothing earth-shattering, but realistic moves that would help improve the team.

2018 STAFF

Head Coach: Kalani Sitake
Assistant Head Coach/Special Teams/Safeties: Ed Lamb
Offensive Coordinator: Ty Detmer
Defensive Coordinator/LB: Ilaisa Tuiaki
Quarterbacks: Jason Beck
Offensive Line: Mike Empey
Wide Receivers : Aaron Roderick
Tight Ends: Steve Clark
Running Backs: Reno Mahe
Defensive Line: Steve Kaufusi
Cornerbacks: Jenaro Gilford
Strength & Conditioning: Nu'u Tafisi

Statistics: Posted by YNot — Tue Nov 21, 2017 10:41 am

Re: 2016 BYU Coaching Staff

2017-11-20T23:20:14-06:00

It's obvious things are headed the wrong way and drastic change is needed. It's hard for me to know what that should look like, but if Sitake presses forward with the status quo, he needs to be let go. If Holmoe tries to do that, intervention is needed there as well.

Statistics: Posted by Jarhead — Mon Nov 20, 2017 11:20 pm

Re: 2016 BYU Coaching Staff

2017-11-20T22:41:39-06:00

What a disaster.

Statistics: Posted by Cougs_Rule — Mon Nov 20, 2017 10:41 pm

Re: 2016 BYU Coaching Staff

2017-11-20T22:19:20-06:00

Would KS be willing to step-down to coordinator role? Would he be willing to cut ties with tuiaki? I never would have let KS assemble this staff if I'm Holmoe. Too much "family". Not enough experience. But then, Holmoes coaching days werent the prettiest.

Statistics: Posted by BroncoBot — Mon Nov 20, 2017 10:19 pm

Re: 2016 BYU Coaching Staff

2017-11-20T20:38:59-06:00

STAFF COMPLETE

Head Coach: Kalani Sitake
Assistant Head Coach/Special Teams/Safeties: Ed Lamb
Offensive Coordinator/QB: Ty Detmer
Defensive Coordinator/LB: Ilaisa Tuiaki
Offensive Line: Mike Empey
Wide Receivers : Ben Cahoon
Tight Ends: Steve Clark
Running Backs: Reno Mahe
Defensive Line: Steve Kaufusi
Cornerbacks: Jenaro Gilford
Strength & Conditioning: Nu'u Tafisi
Asst. Strength & Conditioning: AJ Middleton
Director of Football Operations: Russell Tialavea
Director of Recruiting: Tevita Ofahengaue
Graduate Assistant: Jan Jorgensen
Graduate Assistant: Vince Feula
Graduate Assistant: J.D. Falslev
Who on this list deserves to keep their jobs?
My Initial thought was fire them all. But then I came back to reality and remembered this is good ole cheap handcuff themselves in every possible way BYU. We all know Kalani, Ed Lamb and Ty Detmer are not going anywhere. Steve Clark, Steve Kafusi, Mike Empy, Jenaro Gilford, Russell, Tevita and the GA`s should be back.

The 3 I think should be fired are..
Ben Cahoon. Can anyone think of a group with a worst season? Drope after drope all year long. Weak routes and lack of getting separation especially when the corner is jamming them has been the MO all season long. Cahoon has proven to not be a good coach.
Reno Mahe. The running back group has been dysfunctional and unimpressive this year. The lack of coaching experience I think caught up to Reno this year. 19 year olds need a coach not a BFF.
Nu'u Tafisi. I will admit I know nothing about him or exactly what he does. But there is a lot of chatter about him from people who do know so I am just going with them on this one.
Ilaisa Tuiaki. I am not sure he should be fired but demoted absolutely. Kalani it's time you take the defense over. Kafusi needs to go back to the Dline and Tuiaki needs to go back to the linbackers. That worked last year what they did this year did not.
The only one of those 4 that most likely will be fired is Cahoon. The S&C coach and Tuiaki are best friends with Sitake and will not be fired. Sitake should not take over the defense, Ed Lamb should. Sitake wouldn't be any better than Tuiaki.

I thought about Ed also. Ultimately I'm really really hoping for Gary Anderson.

Statistics: Posted by a1247 — Mon Nov 20, 2017 8:38 pm

Re: 2016 BYU Coaching Staff

2017-11-20T08:48:22-06:00

STAFF COMPLETE

Head Coach: Kalani Sitake
Assistant Head Coach/Special Teams/Safeties: Ed Lamb
Offensive Coordinator/QB: Ty Detmer
Defensive Coordinator/LB: Ilaisa Tuiaki
Offensive Line: Mike Empey
Wide Receivers : Ben Cahoon
Tight Ends: Steve Clark
Running Backs: Reno Mahe
Defensive Line: Steve Kaufusi
Cornerbacks: Jenaro Gilford
Strength & Conditioning: Nu'u Tafisi
Asst. Strength & Conditioning: AJ Middleton
Director of Football Operations: Russell Tialavea
Director of Recruiting: Tevita Ofahengaue
Graduate Assistant: Jan Jorgensen
Graduate Assistant: Vince Feula
Graduate Assistant: J.D. Falslev
Who on this list deserves to keep their jobs?
My Initial thought was fire them all. But then I came back to reality and remembered this is good ole cheap handcuff themselves in every possible way BYU. We all know Kalani, Ed Lamb and Ty Detmer are not going anywhere. Steve Clark, Steve Kafusi, Mike Empy, Jenaro Gilford, Russell, Tevita and the GA`s should be back.

The 3 I think should be fired are..
Ben Cahoon. Can anyone think of a group with a worst season? Drope after drope all year long. Weak routes and lack of getting separation especially when the corner is jamming them has been the MO all season long. Cahoon has proven to not be a good coach.
Reno Mahe. The running back group has been dysfunctional and unimpressive this year. The lack of coaching experience I think caught up to Reno this year. 19 year olds need a coach not a BFF.
Nu'u Tafisi. I will admit I know nothing about him or exactly what he does. But there is a lot of chatter about him from people who do know so I am just going with them on this one.
Ilaisa Tuiaki. I am not sure he should be fired but demoted absolutely. Kalani it's time you take the defense over. Kafusi needs to go back to the Dline and Tuiaki needs to go back to the linbackers. That worked last year what they did this year did not.

The only one of those 4 that most likely will be fired is Cahoon. The S&C coach and Tuiaki are best friends with Sitake and will not be fired. Sitake should not take over the defense, Ed Lamb should. Sitake wouldn't be any better than Tuiaki.

Statistics: Posted by frdbtr — Mon Nov 20, 2017 8:48 am

Re: 2016 BYU Coaching Staff

2017-11-19T17:28:05-06:00

STAFF COMPLETE

Head Coach: Kalani Sitake
Assistant Head Coach/Special Teams/Safeties: Ed Lamb
Offensive Coordinator/QB: Ty Detmer
Defensive Coordinator/LB: Ilaisa Tuiaki
Offensive Line: Mike Empey
Wide Receivers : Ben Cahoon
Tight Ends: Steve Clark
Running Backs: Reno Mahe
Defensive Line: Steve Kaufusi
Cornerbacks: Jenaro Gilford
Strength & Conditioning: Nu'u Tafisi
Asst. Strength & Conditioning: AJ Middleton
Director of Football Operations: Russell Tialavea
Director of Recruiting: Tevita Ofahengaue
Graduate Assistant: Jan Jorgensen
Graduate Assistant: Vince Feula
Graduate Assistant: J.D. Falslev
Who on this list deserves to keep their jobs?

My Initial thought was fire them all. But then I came back to reality and remembered this is good ole cheap handcuff themselves in every possible way BYU. We all know Kalani, Ed Lamb and Ty Detmer are not going anywhere. Steve Clark, Steve Kafusi, Mike Empy, Jenaro Gilford, Russell, Tevita and the GA`s should be back.

The 3 I think should be fired are..
Ben Cahoon. Can anyone think of a group with a worst season? Drope after drope all year long. Weak routes and lack of getting separation especially when the corner is jamming them has been the MO all season long. Cahoon has proven to not be a good coach.
Reno Mahe. The running back group has been dysfunctional and unimpressive this year. The lack of coaching experience I think caught up to Reno this year. 19 year olds need a coach not a BFF.
Nu'u Tafisi. I will admit I know nothing about him or exactly what he does. But there is a lot of chatter about him from people who do know so I am just going with them on this one.
Ilaisa Tuiaki. I am not sure he should be fired but demoted absolutely. Kalani it's time you take the defense over. Kafusi needs to go back to the Dline and Tuiaki needs to go back to the linbackers. That worked last year what they did this year did not.

Statistics: Posted by a1247 — Sun Nov 19, 2017 5:28 pm

Re: 2016 BYU Coaching Staff

2017-11-19T12:29:01-06:00

None. Holmoe doesn't deserve his job either.

Truth

Statistics: Posted by SpiffCoug — Sun Nov 19, 2017 12:29 pm

Re: 2016 BYU Coaching Staff

2017-11-19T10:58:53-06:00

None. Holmoe doesn't deserve his job either.

Statistics: Posted by Gunk — Sun Nov 19, 2017 10:58 am