Elder Nielson
- craigoscarson
- Pro
- Posts: 3268
- Joined: Tue Nov 17, 2009 11:05 am
- Fan Level: BYU Fanatic
- Prediction Group: CougarCorner
Re: Elder Nielson
You were in 1st grade in 1990? wow I'm oldBroncoBot wrote:HA HA ha. haven't heard that since about 1st grade.snoscythe wrote:The song goes: We had Sheide, Nielson, Wilson, and McMahon, Young, Bosco, Covey, now Ty's the new man!"
" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
-
- Recruit
- Posts: 58
- Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 12:22 pm
- Fan Level: BYU Fan
- Prediction Group: CougarCorner
- Location: Charleston, Illinois
Re: Elder Nielson
When Gary Sheide was a senior, he led BYU to its first bowl game. You have to remember that there weren't very many bowl games in those days (1974), and it was only the fourth Fiesta Bowl, which was created to give the WAC a chance at a bowl game (in those days, it was an earier version of the MWC struggle to break into the BCS).
Sheide, a juco transfer, was a national figure in the new pass-happy offense (which was VERY innovative at the time) for the two years he started. From BYU's profile:
I forget the name of the QB who replaced him, but it was all OK state after that. The next year, Gifford Nielsen was the starter and the rest is history.
As for Virgil Carter, he was 11th in voting for the Heisman in 1966, but this was before the Lavelle Edwards era and Carter's prowess wasn't repeated by subsequent quarterbacks until Sheide began the long and glorious stretch. I saw Carter play when I was at the LTM (Lanaguage Training Mission ... predecessor to the MTC). They let us go to all the home games back then, and even gave us missionaries free tickets. I was in the LTM for most of the 1966 season, so got to see Carter a lot. Prior to that, BYU rarely won a football game, and everyone pretty much blew it off and only went to the games as something to do while waiting for basketball season.
Sheide, a juco transfer, was a national figure in the new pass-happy offense (which was VERY innovative at the time) for the two years he started. From BYU's profile:
I lived in Phoenix at the time and was able to get some nosebleed tickets to the game. BYU went out to a 6-0 first quarter lead against Oklahoma State and Sheide was dominating. Then everything collapsed when he went down with an injury and never returned to the game.As a senior, he garnered accolades for leading the Cougars to a 7-4-1 season. His honors include the Sammy Baugh Trophy, Most Valuable Player in the WAC, First Team All-WAC, WAC Offensive Player of the Year and player of the week honors from the WAC, UPI and Associated Press. Sheide also led the NCAA with 388 yards passing and led the Cougars to their first bowl appearance.
I forget the name of the QB who replaced him, but it was all OK state after that. The next year, Gifford Nielsen was the starter and the rest is history.
As for Virgil Carter, he was 11th in voting for the Heisman in 1966, but this was before the Lavelle Edwards era and Carter's prowess wasn't repeated by subsequent quarterbacks until Sheide began the long and glorious stretch. I saw Carter play when I was at the LTM (Lanaguage Training Mission ... predecessor to the MTC). They let us go to all the home games back then, and even gave us missionaries free tickets. I was in the LTM for most of the 1966 season, so got to see Carter a lot. Prior to that, BYU rarely won a football game, and everyone pretty much blew it off and only went to the games as something to do while waiting for basketball season.
-
- All-American
- Posts: 1672
- Joined: Thu Nov 19, 2009 11:43 am
- Fan Level: BYU Fan
- Prediction Group: CougarCorner
- Has thanked: 264 times
- Been thanked: 12 times
Re: Elder Nielson
Carter was phenomenal! I was at the Utep game when he set the ncaa total offense record. Utep had a very good team then. He had 500+ yards passing and running. He could do what Young could but was 20 lbs. or so lighter. He played in the nfl I think for Chicago. In one game he was running down the sidelines when a tackler came up and hit him. He pirouetted around him and kept going. To this day I've seen few moves to beat it. He should have won the Heisman but at that time the ncaa never looked to the inner mountain area. If Hill could pass as accurately as Carter I believe we'd be undefeated.
To get back to Nielson, he's the only qb to become a general authority which is phenomenal for anyone.
To get back to Nielson, he's the only qb to become a general authority which is phenomenal for anyone.
-
- TV Analyst
- Posts: 10725
- Joined: Sat Nov 28, 2009 2:41 am
- Fan Level: BYU Fan
- Prediction Group: CougarCorner
Re: Elder Nielson
Carter - Bears and Bengals iirc.
Carter played for BYU in my early to mid teenage years. I was raised by a single mother of five and other rhan 1 U game, never could afford the luxury of a college football ticket. For the 1 U game, my older brother's best friend drove us to it when we lived in Sandy area.
A trip clear down to Provo was out of reach. Even when we moved to Provo, no luxuries like that.
Amazingly, while attending BYU for under-grad and U for MBA, I never was able to attend a football game at either school. I would try to listen to KSL while working for my dad, but "all of that noise and racket" usually resulted in him turning the radio off in less than 15 minutes.
BYU did have a drawing that provided some free basketball tickets to students. You got to enter a ticket into one of the jars organized by section. I was smart and always put mine in the nosebleed jar and did get a free ticket to several games.
I was armed with a BS and an MBA and started my career in So. CAL just as Sheide and Edwards got launched.
[ Post made via Mobile Device ]
Carter played for BYU in my early to mid teenage years. I was raised by a single mother of five and other rhan 1 U game, never could afford the luxury of a college football ticket. For the 1 U game, my older brother's best friend drove us to it when we lived in Sandy area.
A trip clear down to Provo was out of reach. Even when we moved to Provo, no luxuries like that.
Amazingly, while attending BYU for under-grad and U for MBA, I never was able to attend a football game at either school. I would try to listen to KSL while working for my dad, but "all of that noise and racket" usually resulted in him turning the radio off in less than 15 minutes.
BYU did have a drawing that provided some free basketball tickets to students. You got to enter a ticket into one of the jars organized by section. I was smart and always put mine in the nosebleed jar and did get a free ticket to several games.
I was armed with a BS and an MBA and started my career in So. CAL just as Sheide and Edwards got launched.
[ Post made via Mobile Device ]

Anae just might be the guy. Wisconsin DC says Anae is totally unpredictable because he just runs a bunch of plays with no rhyme or reason. Whooped Butt on Houston DC for 3 of 4 quarters. Destroyed Texas DC and HC careers.
-
- All-American
- Posts: 1672
- Joined: Thu Nov 19, 2009 11:43 am
- Fan Level: BYU Fan
- Prediction Group: CougarCorner
- Has thanked: 264 times
- Been thanked: 12 times
Re: Elder Nielson
This is a good story Bib. I had to earn all my $ for school. I had to get 2 loans to finish, one from my dad and one from the school but I paid them back without any government interference.
-
- TV Analyst
- Posts: 10725
- Joined: Sat Nov 28, 2009 2:41 am
- Fan Level: BYU Fan
- Prediction Group: CougarCorner
Re: Elder Nielson
Back in the good ole days - Tuition was $240 per semester plus books. I got married young and had my first 2 kids while still in college but with no medical insurance. Back then doctor and hospital bills came in at just under $500 for each baby.
Rented a farm house in Midway for $35 a month. Then the commute got to me after a car wreck in Provo Canyon, so I rented a 2 bedroom basement apartment on 3rd south in Provo for $65 monthly. Then a farm house at 1168 W 500 South for $95. You could see daylight through a hole in the bathroom wall. I managed to get a Farmers Home Administration mortgage and buy a new Boise Cascade pre-fab home in Heber for $17, 500 during grad school and bum a ride to and from SLC daily from my dad's friend.
I did have to borrow an old car with expired plates my stepmother had parked out in the field when she married my dad and take our a $300 student loan to finish the last semester of graduate school. Other than that, TA, part-time weekend job, and playing in a band squeaked me through.
It is shocking what it costs students today to get the same education and start a family.
[ Post made via Mobile Device ]
Rented a farm house in Midway for $35 a month. Then the commute got to me after a car wreck in Provo Canyon, so I rented a 2 bedroom basement apartment on 3rd south in Provo for $65 monthly. Then a farm house at 1168 W 500 South for $95. You could see daylight through a hole in the bathroom wall. I managed to get a Farmers Home Administration mortgage and buy a new Boise Cascade pre-fab home in Heber for $17, 500 during grad school and bum a ride to and from SLC daily from my dad's friend.
I did have to borrow an old car with expired plates my stepmother had parked out in the field when she married my dad and take our a $300 student loan to finish the last semester of graduate school. Other than that, TA, part-time weekend job, and playing in a band squeaked me through.
It is shocking what it costs students today to get the same education and start a family.
[ Post made via Mobile Device ]

Last edited by Cougarbib on Sun Oct 06, 2013 6:58 pm, edited 3 times in total.
Anae just might be the guy. Wisconsin DC says Anae is totally unpredictable because he just runs a bunch of plays with no rhyme or reason. Whooped Butt on Houston DC for 3 of 4 quarters. Destroyed Texas DC and HC careers.
- bigbluepuma
- All-American
- Posts: 1032
- Joined: Mon Dec 14, 2009 12:40 pm
- Fan Level: BYU Blue Goggled Homer
- Prediction Group: CougarCorner
Re: Elder Nielson
profgeek wrote:When Gary Sheide was a senior, he led BYU to its first bowl game. You have to remember that there weren't very many bowl games in those days (1974), and it was only the fourth Fiesta Bowl, which was created to give the WAC a chance at a bowl game (in those days, it was an earier version of the MWC struggle to break into the BCS).
Sheide, a juco transfer, was a national figure in the new pass-happy offense (which was VERY innovative at the time) for the two years he started. From BYU's profile:
I lived in Phoenix at the time and was able to get some nosebleed tickets to the game. BYU went out to a 6-0 first quarter lead against Oklahoma State and Sheide was dominating. Then everything collapsed when he went down with an injury and never returned to the game.As a senior, he garnered accolades for leading the Cougars to a 7-4-1 season. His honors include the Sammy Baugh Trophy, Most Valuable Player in the WAC, First Team All-WAC, WAC Offensive Player of the Year and player of the week honors from the WAC, UPI and Associated Press. Sheide also led the NCAA with 388 yards passing and led the Cougars to their first bowl appearance.
I forget the name of the QB who replaced him, but it was all OK state after that. The next year, Gifford Nielsen was the starter and the rest is history.
As for Virgil Carter, he was 11th in voting for the Heisman in 1966, but this was before the Lavelle Edwards era and Carter's prowess wasn't repeated by subsequent quarterbacks until Sheide began the long and glorious stretch. I saw Carter play when I was at the LTM (Lanaguage Training Mission ... predecessor to the MTC). They let us go to all the home games back then, and even gave us missionaries free tickets. I was in the LTM for most of the 1966 season, so got to see Carter a lot. Prior to that, BYU rarely won a football game, and everyone pretty much blew it off and only went to the games as something to do while waiting for basketball season.
The backup's name was Giles. He might have been a decent QB if he had any PT, but I don't think they had a lot of blowouts that year. After the first 4 ( I think) games, they were listed in a nationally released article about the worst ten teams in America; by the end of the regular season, they broke the top twenty.
If Sheide had not been injured, they would have completely dominated OSU. As it was, I remember the game still being close, but it was very obvious that Giles wasn't Sheide.
-
- TV Analyst
- Posts: 10725
- Joined: Sat Nov 28, 2009 2:41 am
- Fan Level: BYU Fan
- Prediction Group: CougarCorner
Re: Elder Nielson
Sheide dislocated his shoulder vs Okie State. He was drafted as 2nd QB taken in the draft. Bengals took him in 3rd round. Elbow injury kept him from ever playing.
My research indicated that after finishing 5-6 his first season as a junior jc transfer and starting 0-3-1 his senior season, this wierd new passing offense finally clicked. BYU won out and was winning the bowl game until he got injured. They won the WAC - ASU and AZ were still in the WAC then.
Sheide and his brother both converted to The LDS Church - baptized the same day.
Sheide turned BYU down in a short conversation out of high school and told Edwards he had never hear of his school. He went to JC to play baseball and was recruited in football, basketball, and baseball.
QB injuries at the JC resulted in him deciding to give FB a shot.
Did great. Had offers from every conference. Then Edwards came again. His mother liked Edwards and told Sheide to visit. The mountains, pretty girls - all convinced him when Edwards acknowledged that BYU did have an All American RB - but they were going to switch to the pass and change college football.
Sound familiar.
A baseball player who had never heard of BYU and was not LDS came to BYU to change college football forever because his mother liked LaVell Edwards.
[ Post made via Mobile Device ]
My research indicated that after finishing 5-6 his first season as a junior jc transfer and starting 0-3-1 his senior season, this wierd new passing offense finally clicked. BYU won out and was winning the bowl game until he got injured. They won the WAC - ASU and AZ were still in the WAC then.
Sheide and his brother both converted to The LDS Church - baptized the same day.
Sheide turned BYU down in a short conversation out of high school and told Edwards he had never hear of his school. He went to JC to play baseball and was recruited in football, basketball, and baseball.
QB injuries at the JC resulted in him deciding to give FB a shot.
Did great. Had offers from every conference. Then Edwards came again. His mother liked Edwards and told Sheide to visit. The mountains, pretty girls - all convinced him when Edwards acknowledged that BYU did have an All American RB - but they were going to switch to the pass and change college football.
Sound familiar.
A baseball player who had never heard of BYU and was not LDS came to BYU to change college football forever because his mother liked LaVell Edwards.
[ Post made via Mobile Device ]

Anae just might be the guy. Wisconsin DC says Anae is totally unpredictable because he just runs a bunch of plays with no rhyme or reason. Whooped Butt on Houston DC for 3 of 4 quarters. Destroyed Texas DC and HC careers.
-
- All-American
- Posts: 1672
- Joined: Thu Nov 19, 2009 11:43 am
- Fan Level: BYU Fan
- Prediction Group: CougarCorner
- Has thanked: 264 times
- Been thanked: 12 times
Re: Elder Nielson
Maybe this should be in the lounge. When I did my student teaching in SLC I had barely enough to pay rent and eat. I had a cheap but good guitar and my roommate wanted one. While he was trying them out I went down to the Gibson section with my tongue hanging out. I was playing this dream Hummingbird when it was time to go. I asked the guy how much it was and he said $390 but it's $100 off. I might have that in my pocket now but it was a fortune then. Then for some reason I asked him how much down. He said $50. My roommate immediately said he'd give $50 for my guitar. Through the shock I asked if I could call my dad and come back next day. My dad said he'd back me. I got the dream guitar and somehow made every payment. It changed my life. The Hummingbird is worth at least 10xs what I paid for it but it ain't for sale.Cougarbib wrote:Back in the good ole days - Tuition was $240 per semester plus books. I got married young and had my first 2 kids while still in college but with no medical insurance. Back then doctor and hospital bills came in at just under $500 for each baby.
Rented a farm house in Midway for $35 a month. Then the commute got to me after a car wreck in Provo Canyon, so I rented a 2 bedroom basement apartment on 3rd south in Provo for $65 monthly. Then a farm house at 1168 W 500 South for $95. You could see daylight through a hole in the bathroom wall. I managed to get a Farmers Home Administration mortgage and buy a new Boise Cascade pre-fab home in Heber for $17, 500 during grad school and bum a ride to and from SLC daily from my dad's friend.
I did have to borrow an old car with expired plates my stepmother had parked out in the field when she married my dad and take our a $300 student loan to finish the last semester of graduate school. Other than that, TA, part-time weekend job, and playing in a band squeaked me through.
It is shocking what it costs students today to get the same education and start a family.
[ Post made via Mobile Device ]
Back on track, this was about the time Elder qb was shredding defenses.