coachK wrote:
I don't get it. Why all the love for Santa Clara. We got no seed, :angry: they got a 4 seed. Which, incidentally is the same seed they would have received in a WCC tourney if there had been one. :roll:
Santa Clara has a win vs. a #1 seed. They beat Stanford and we lost to them. On BYU's side the best win is vs. #18 Cal, which is nice, but that's about all BYU has on the resume besides winning the conference. The committee rewards tougher schedules. We're all BYU fans, but if you understand what the committee likes to base these decisions on and look objectively, SCU actually does have a slightly stronger overall resume.
In conference it's really almost the same. They tied each other and both lost to USF. BYU finished higher because SCU also tied St. Mary's. Here are the rpi's of the teams SCU and BYU played. It's close, but the main difference is the committee wants to reward a stronger non-conference schedule. SCU played more good teams and BYU played more teams ranked below 100. Also, the tie vs. Cal Poly really hurts BYU.
Only the top 4 teams are seeded. After that the committee gives home games to the next highest set of teams and then only cares about matching up the unseeded teams in a way that makes sense for travel. They don't care about giving the top 4 seeds the easiest possible opponent in the second round.
For BYU it also comes down to that one weekend of losing to USF and tying Santa Clara. BYU had a 1-0 lead at USF. No excuses. They blew it and should not have lost. They should have won both those games. But had they at least beaten USF we're not even having this discussion and BYU is a seeded team. They were capable but just had a bad weekend. Fortunately they got the wakeup call and have played great since. They're fully capable of beating Stanford.
SCU vs rpi 1-25:
L vs. #2 Penn State
W vs. #5 Stanford
L vs. #10 Notre Dame
L vs. #18 California
BYU vs. rpi 1-25:
L vs. #5 Stanford
W vs. #18 California
SCU vs. rpi 26-50:
L vs. #27 Arizona
W vs. #44 Northwestern
W vs. #50 Oklahoma
BYU vs. rpi 26-50:
W vs. #43 Long Beach State
W vs. #45 Nebraska
SCU vs. rpi 51-100:
W vs. #69 Kansas
BYU vs. rpi 51-100:
Tie vs. #96 Cal Poly
SCU vs. rpi 101+
W vs. #101 UC Davis
W vs. #119 CS Northridge
W vs. #190 UC Irvine
BYU vs. rpi 101+
W vs. #102 Utah
W vs. #118 Oregon State
W vs. #153 UNLV
W vs. #155 Colorado
W vs. #197 Utah State