Archived Topic

Frustrating 2022--but big changes coming

by Fido · 10/29/2022

Sponsored Advertisementad content
F
Fido
I previously posted about what looks like coaching staff changes coming for next year--but checked on the status of players to determine who the players are who might be moving on. We'll know better when they announce the players being honored vs Utah Tech on November 19. Of the 122 players currently listed as on the roster, I count 40 who possibly might not be back next year.



Players listed as seniors on the roster

Defense

Chaz Ah You DB/LB (may use a redshirt? 5th year in program)

Matthew Criddle DB

Lorenzo Fauatea DL

Kaleb Hayes DB

D'Angelo Mandell DB

Malik Moore DB

Pepe Tanuvasa DL

Alden Tofa DL

Earl Tuioti-Mariner DL



Offense

Christopher Brooks RB

Houston Heimuli FB

Chris Jackson WR

Lopini Katoa RB

Lane Lunt TE

Gunner Romney WR

Joe Tukuafu OL



5th year players (Juniors) in 2022

Defense

Jackson Kaufusi LB

Hayden Livingston DB

Atunaisa Mahe DL

Keenan Pili LB

Alema Pilimai DL

Morgan Pyper DB

Gabe Summers DL

Max Tooley LB

Payton Wilgar LB (wife recently instagramed they can't wait to get out of here)



Offense

Clark Barrington OL

Brayden Cosper WR

Jaren Hall QB

Harris LaChance OL



Special Teams

Britton Hogan LS

Jake Oldroyd K/P



4th year players (underclassmen) in 2022

Defense

Jacob Boren DB

Ben Bywater LB

Ammon Hannemann DB

Caden Haws DL

George Udo DB



Offense

Jackson McChesney RB

Isaac Rex TE

Masen Wake TE

Carter Wheat TE



I'll update the list as we hear more.
J
jadesroom
Given the state of BYU's program today, I foresee several players entering the transfer portal.
B
byufan4ever
Here's the players that I would be sad to see leave:



*Jaren Hall, JR - This season is not helping his draft status so I can't see him going pro. But maybe he transfers to a quality program in need of an experience QB for one season. I believe in him and would like to see him stay.



*Jacob Conover, FR - Hopefully he doesn't become frustrated and leaves. He is supposedly the future. Might as well rest Hall and see what he has now.



*Miles Davis, FR - The only RB to really show anything. Has speed and elusiveness that no one else at his position has.



*Kody Epps, FR - Has shown potential.



*Keanu Hill, SO - Had a great game against Wyoming, but has kind of disappeared.



*Chase Roberts, FR - Started off strong then got injured



*Puka Nacua, JR - I feel like he is the life and soul of this team.



*Tyler Batty, SO - One of the few lone bright spots on the DL.



*John Nelson, SO - I would rather have 5 walk-ons like him than one 4 star recruit that thinks that the starter job should just be given to them.



*Max Tooley, JR - I could do without his shoe throwing, but if that's what it takes to get someone with some aggressiveness then maybe I am ok with it.



*Ben Bywater, SO - Shows up every once in a while to make a TFL.



*Harper Micah, FR - Talented and shows promise.



*Gabe Jeudy-Lally, SO - Decent and...we need some guys to stick around.



If anyone else transfers...good luck to ya finding an FBS team that will take ya.
F
Fido
One worry I have in the QB situation is that Conover is actually in his 3rd year in the program in 2022--he used a redshirt and the covid year to still be a freshman--but how long will he wait at #2? It sounds like Fennegan is the next guy up after him, but I've never heard much of any of the other QBs on the roster. Hopefully another guy is coming in the next year or two.
N
nuk13
Jackson McChesney is a mystery to me. He had 228 yards against UMass in 2019. I don't think he's had that many yards in all the rest of his games.
Sponsored Advertisementad content
J
jadesroom
Fido wrote:

One worry I have in the QB situation is that Conover is actually in his 3rd year in the program in 2022--he used a redshirt and the covid year to still be a freshman--but how long will he wait at #2? It sounds like Fennegan is the next guy up after him, but I've never heard much of any of the other QBs on the roster. Hopefully another guy is coming in the next year or two.


I worry about the lack of play time given to any of the backups this year. An injured Hall is no better than an injured Riley Nelson. In both instances the players decided if they would play or not, and in both instances the team suffered. I have as much faith in Aaron Roderick as I did in Brandon Dolman. Conover is supposed to be the heir apparent at quarterback, but at one time so were James Lark and Jason Munns.
B
byufan4ever
jadesroom wrote:


One worry I have in the QB situation is that Conover is actually in his 3rd year in the program in 2022--he used a redshirt and the covid year to still be a freshman--but how long will he wait at #2? It sounds like Fennegan is the next guy up after him, but I've never heard much of any of the other QBs on the roster. Hopefully another guy is coming in the next year or two.


I worry about the lack of play time given to any of the backups this year. An injured Hall is no better than an injured Riley Nelson. In both instances the players decided if they would play or not, and in both instances the team suffered. I have as much faith in Aaron Roderick as I did in Brandon Dolman. Conover is supposed to be the heir apparent at quarterback, but at one time so were James Lark and Jason Munns.


Haha, Hall playing injured also reminded me of Riley Nelson. Remember the Nelson/Heaps controversy? This place was on fire with the team and fans alike divided. Oh man, I forgot about Lark and Munns. I was pretty excited for what seemed like very deep QB depth at the time...
F
Fido
In his Monday press briefing, Sitake mentioned that there are 13 seniors who will exhaust their eligibility and others who either have graduated and have a job lined up or will be taking a shot at the NFL so they will be having those discussions with players this week during the bye to get them the information so they can make a decision about their future. I ran the list and came up with these 13 seniors.



RB Christopher Brooks

DB Matthew Criddle

DL Lorenzo Fauatea

DB Kaleb Hayes

FB Houston Heimuli

WR Chris Jackson

RB Lopini Katoa

TE Lane Lunt

DB D'Angelo Mandell

DL Pepe Tanuvasa

DL Alden Tofa

DL Earl Tuioti-Mariner

OL Joe Tukuafu



These seniors may be using/applying for a redshirt year due to injuries and wouldn't be in the 13 mentioned by coach above:

DB/LB Chaz Ah You

DB Malik Moore

WR Gunner Romney



I guess we'll have to wait and see if these guys and any juniors are moving on as well.
F
Fido
Per Mitch Harper, here is the list of 34 players to be honored on Saturday's final home game:


1592238841783459851

Seniors

RB Christopher Brooks

DB Matthew Criddle

DL Lorenzo Fauatea

DB Kaleb Hayes

FB Houston Heimuli

WR Chris Jackson

RB Lopini Katoa

TE Lane Lunt

DB D'Angelo Mandell

DL Pepe Tanuvasa

DL Alden Tofa

DL Earl Tuioti-Mariner

OL Joe Tukuafu



Juniors

OL Clark Barrington

WR Brayden Cosper

OL Blake Freeland

QB Jaren Hall

LS Britton Hogan

LB Jackson Kaufusi

OL Harris LaChance

DB Hayden Livingston

DL Atunaisa Mahe

RB Jackson McChesney

WR Puka Nacua

K Jake Oldroyd

LB Keenan Pili

DL Alema Pilimai

LB Morgan Pyper

WR Gunner Romney

DL Gabe Summers

LB Max Tooley

DB George Udo

FB Masen Wake

LB Payton Wilgar
F
Fido
Surprises to me are McChesney--he's a 4th year player but must have a job lined up or something, Gunner Romney kind of--I thought he might come back but sounds like 5 years are enough, and Isaac Rex not being on the list--I thought he might be giving pro football a go.
Sponsored Advertisementad content
B
byufan4ever
So what does it mean if a junior is on this list? They probably not coming back?
F
Fido
byufan4ever wrote:

So what does it mean if a junior is on this list? They probably not coming back?


Those included on this list are those who are considering moving on after this season (NFL, job prospects, completed degree, moving on, etc.) so they are going to be honored this year in the final home game. They DO have the option based on future conversations to return as they still have some eligibility remaining. Examples from last year are Katoa and Romney who were honored in senior night but then opted to return. So it is not a definitive list, but are those who would need to do something to stay--like get into grad school, pull their name back from NFL consideration, etc.
F
Fido
3 more juniors added to the honoree list:

Chaz Ah You LB

Ammon Hannemann DB

Malik Moore DB
F
Fido
Basically the list now includes all those listed as seniors or juniors with the exception of:

DB Mory Bamba (Junior)

DB Jacob Boren (Junior)

LB Tavita Gagnier (Junior)

RB Hinckley Ropati (Junior)

OL Lisala Tai (Junior)



The list does have Sophomores:

DB Ammon Hannemann

RB Jackson McChesney



The free covid year has everything kinda crazy. In any case, the team could possibly lose 37 of the 123 players on the team this year. They could be very young and inexperienced in the first year in the Big 12.
B
byufan4ever
I just saw that Jay Drew said that Hall is 95% gone and Puka is 75% gone. Not sure how accurate that is, but what does everyone else think?



I really want Conover to play AT LEAST half of the game against Utah Tech. I wouldn't even mind him starting and playing the entire game. Not because I don't like Hall, but Hall has been banged up and we really shouldn't need him this game. Heck, if Hall is really 95% on the way out he should probably remove himself from the game. Why risk injury? What does he have to gain by playing against Utah Tech?
Sponsored Advertisementad content
J
jadesroom
Young and inexperienced may not be the worst thing in the world. We'll see. This year we were old and experienced and disappointing.



I too would love to see Conover play. But then again, he should have played when Hall was injured and ineffective.
F
Fido
Gunner Romney told KSL sports that he is "most likely be heading out after this year". He indicated it has been a frustrating year to start out healthy and then suffer the kidney injury that has kept him on the sideline. He also said he is "questionable" for the Utah Tech game today.
B
byufan4ever
The decommits are starting to roll in. First Hawaii DL Stanley Raas flips his commitment to Utah and now RB Landen Chambers from Texas has re-opened his recruiting. I thought everyone wanted to play for BYU next year in the Big 12...
F
Fido
1594697731532066819

Puka has accepted a Senior Bowl invite. Which means he is not returning.
F
Fido
1595446425290170368

Blake Freeland is also going to the Senior Bowl.
Page 1 of 2
This is an archived topic from the original CougarCorner forum. New replies are not accepted.