Isaac Luatua - Where's BYU???

BYU better wake up w/ this kid. He's a high quality athlete - w/ Alabama, Oregon, Tennessee, UCLA, Boston College & others sniffing around. He's a Top 20 Offensive Guard, LDS, likes BYU & has not been offered yet. IMHO - you don't pass on quality athletes. Supposedly the Cougs are loaded w/ O-Guards. But guess what - injuries always happen - always.

Ddawg wrote:
BYU better wake up w/ this kid. He's a high quality athlete - w/ Alabama, Oregon, Tennessee, UCLA, Boston College & others sniffing around. He's a Top 20 Offensive Guard, LDS, likes BYU & has not been offered yet. IMHO - you don't pass on quality athletes. Supposedly the Cougs are loaded w/ O-Guards. But guess what - injuries always happen - always.

Amen, brotha. And guess what - o/l guards can make EXCELLENT centers, and even right tackles (if they're athletic enough). If there's 2 "positions" (term used loosely) you can never have too many QUALITY players, it's o-line, and QB.

Sounds like the lack of an offer from BYU has really cooled his interest. Too bad. Never can have enough quality linemen.



http://byu.scout.com/2/968448.html

He does sound like a stud but BYU is loaded at both OG and C. We are really going to be hurting for quality OT though soon and that has obviously been the focus so far this class. Plus, sometimes these kids need to get themselves to camp in order for BYU coaches to really be able to see them up close if they want an offer. Also, if he had definite mission plans (a mission first approach would be even better) I think BYU would probably be all over him. But again, as it is, we are loaded at G, no matter how good he is.



Center/Guard:

Ryan Freeman

Houston Reynolds

Blair Tushaus

Terry Alleto

Fono Vakalahi

Braden Hansen

Terrence Brown

Marco Thorson

Jason Speredon

Nick Alleto

Walter Kaihailahi

Manu Mulitalo

Tuni Kanuch

Tui Crichton

Jordan Black

Lui Lapuaho



Tackle:

Nick Alleto (gone after this year)

Matt Reynolds (likely to leave after this year)

Braden Brown

Brad Wilcox

Michael Yeck

Brock Stringham

Jordan Black



A lot Cougar fans are always complaining that BYU is not quick/athletic enough and that our lineman are too fat but as soon as we seemingly pass (who knows, maybe BYU still might offer) on a 300 pounder (still a junior high school mind you) those same fans get a burr up their butt. You can't have it both ways people.

Mars brings up a good point. Sometimes a school gets turned on to one player and offers before they even become aware of another player. It's possible BYU offered Aiono before they even knew about Luatua and potentially only wanting to sign one guard this class, want to honor their offer to Aiono before they offer Luatua and say "first come first serve".

gmj81 wrote:
Mars brings up a good point. Sometimes a school gets turned on to one player and offers before they even become aware of another player. It's possible BYU offered Aiono before they even knew about Luatua and potentially only wanting to sign one guard this class, want to honor their offer to Aiono before they offer Luatua and say "first come first serve".

I disagree with this approach, and I think Bronco has made it known that the kids who commit first get the schollies. As I recall, Ricky Heimuli lost out for that reason. If BYU wants him, and thinks he will commit now, they will offer him, and if another kid loses out due to looking around, that is not BYU's problem. First Come, First Served is exactly the approach BYU is taking, because they read first come to mean totally committed, and I agree with that.

While I kind of agree with you on that point I think that BYU probably operates a little differently than most schools. This early in the game, they might feel they have to give the first kid time to think about his offer a bit before throwing in the "rush" factor. Getting a commitment from a kid who really doesn't know if he'll fit or wants to be at BYU but is just trying to grab up the offer before another player does doesn't help that kid or BYU at all in the long run if he ends up transferring down the road. Once they've kind of finished the summer camp thing and perhaps gotten a few more offers, then BYU can put the heat on them a little bit because they should have had quite a bit of time to think about things by then and won't feel like they have to jump on the offer right away or not have anything at all.

Aiono also happens to have plans to serve his mission prior to enrolling so that may explain why he even has an offer at this point. It's possible BYU doesn't want any guards from this class who will occupy a scholarship in 2011.

BYU isn't the big school on my mind anymore.

Sounds to me like another Notre Dame commit situation. Anybody that's interested in Tennessee, UCLA, USC, Notre Dame is enough for me to understand why they aren't pursuing. Plus his interest appears low.