BYU OCs and where ARod Ranks

1 replies33 views
byufan4ever

Legend

2.0K posts

First off, howdy! I was a pretty active member way back in the day. Anyways, enjoy this analysis. Agree or disagree, I'd love to hear your comments. Just be nice lol.

Partly just because I like to track these things, but also because I am interested in how Aaron Roderick compares to past offensive coordinators, I looked at every BYU football OC going back to the 2000 season. I tracked their Points Per Game, Total Yards Per Game, Rushing Yards Per Game, Passing Yards Per Game, Total Yards Per Play, Rushing Yards Per Play, and Passing Yards Per Play, along with who was the leading rusher, passer, and receiver.

So, how does ARod compare, and who has been our best OC? It’s not easy because there is no one defining thing or stat that will tell us that. However, there is one constant, and that is that fans will complain about whoever is the current OC. I remember fans complaining about Anae’s “vanilla” offense. In this case I looked at three stats and ranked each OC that spent at least 2 full seasons in charge and then took the average of those three rankings to get the final ranking list. But also remember, there is more to an OC’s job than offensive output. He must also recruit and develop players. Of course, an OC that has better players should be able to put up more points and yards, but that is also dependent on how good of a play caller they are. Those areas are all interwoven together and it’s hard to quantify exactly how much of an offense’s production is due to pure talent vs good playcalling.

The first stat I looked at was Points Per Game (PPG). At the end of the day, the offense needs to score points, and it is the OC’s job to do that. I remember Bronco saying his threshold for both the offense and defense was 24 points. If an offense scores more than 24 then they have done their job and they should win most games. And it’s the defense’s job to hold teams to under 24 points. However, this can be misleading because not all points come from the offense. I am looking at season total points and that includes defensive and special teams TDs. Also, a good defense, and ST, will give the offense good field position, making it easier for them to score more points.

So, an offense that puts up a ton of Total Yards Per Game (TYPG) should be the best, right? Well, they could suffer from the opposite of the previous point. A bad defense and ST could mean that the offense has to go the length of the field to score. Sometimes they are getting more yards more out necessity than because they really are that good. Also, a team could constantly go 80 yards and then settle for FGs, and that does not really make them a better offense.

Lastly, I looked at Total Yards Per Play (TYPP). Regardless if you had to drive 20 yards or 80 yards for a score, how many yards per play is the offense producing? This stat can still be influences by how run or pass heavy the play selection is because even offenses that are really good at running the ball and really bad at passing the ball, will have lower TYPP as passing still generally gets more yards per play.

I’ve included other rushing and passing stats just for comparison but did not rank the OCs on those categories.

Mike Borich comes out of top in my Total Average Rank (Total Ave R) as he ranked #1 in PPG, #1 in TYPG, and #3 in TYPP for a Total Ave R of 1.7. It’s important not note that he only had two seasons, one of which was the best single season in this list which included peak Luke Staley (and Brandon Doman was pretty good too looking at his PYPA). His other season though was horrible and ranks amongst the worst, right down there with Detmer.

In second place is Jeff Grimes. He was third in both PPG and TYPG, and easily first in TYPP. His last season with a stellar Zach Wilson and a very easy Covid schedule does slightly skew his stats, IMO, as his first two seasons were decent, but not nearly as impressive. Personally, I think Grimes’ biggest strength was recruiting and developing OL. I remember fans complaining about his playcalling and there were rumors that in some of our best games it was really ARod calling the shots…

Third and fourth place both go to Robert Anae. He was OC two different times and most fans generally refer to his second stint as Anae 2.0. Interestingly, his stats from both stints are quite similar across the board. With a variety of different rushing/passing/receiving players, he managed to be fairly consistent. While I would not want Anae back now as his best days are clearly behind him, I think we should definitely look back fondly upon his offenses.

5th place is where ARod fits in. He’s above Doman and Detmer, but those are pretty low bars, but at least he’s a good margin above them. He’s much closer to Aane 1.0 then he is to Doman. ARod ranked 5th in PPG and 6th in TYPG, but an impressive 2nd in TYPP. I weighted each of these evenly although a case could be made for the TYPP to be the most important. So, it’s not all bad for our current OC. Note that his stats are up through the 2026 Baylor game. I remember hearing after the Notre Dame game that their defense said our offense was giving them new looks, formations, and motions almost every single play, and that threw them off. ARod “can” be good. But then he can also call the exact same run play 4 times in a row. And we all know that he’s going to be ultra conservative on third and long. I think he has PTSD from the Utah game and is afraid that if his QB throws one more INT it will completely shatter his confidence. Honestly, it looked like Bear had some PTSD from the Utah game as well. But here is where ARod needs to work his magic to get his QB’s head straight because we cannot continue with this playcalling if we are going to be a playoff team. The defense has really carried this team IMO.

The last two places go to Doman and Detmer. I think Doman was a pretty good QB coach, but just struggled as OC. He will forever be the OC that picked Riley Nelson over Jake Heaps. Personally, I was and am in the Nelson camp. I think he made the right choice, but he failed to control the locker room. Detmer was never Sitake’s guy or choice for OC. He was obviously picked by the AD and was way over his head. He went from casually coaching a small HS to OC in division 1 college football. Detmer’s offenses finished last in each of the three categories.

Sponsored Advertisementad content
Tanner M.

Active Member

43 posts

Appreciate you pulling all those numbers together. Fan bases always want to dial up something different until they see an offense stall out without a clear plan.

Look at how Roderick used Bear Bachmeier against Baylor. Calling 15 runs for 54 yards and three scores while milking the clock isn't always flashy, but it wins football games in November. Total yards per game don't mean much if you aren't dictating terms up front.