Cougs_Rule wrote:
Cougs_Rule wrote:
If KC has learned to take of the ball and can distribute, he could have the effect of magic Johnson: Tall, vision, can pass over the top, get to the RIM, and finish at the rim. He would draw ALOT of attention on D and free up outside shooters. This suits his strength best. He is not a good shooter, ugly form.
And Carlino does better as a 2 than a 1, IMO.
KC has length on D at the perimeter could add some much needed perimeter D as well.
What it really come to is a much better mix and match options depending on the opponent.
You should try watching some BYU basketball games. They are fun!
Carlino is far and away our best point guard, and it isn't even close. Sure, carlino shoots better as a 2 guard coming off of screens and working without the ball (that is why they refer to the position as a "shooting" guard). Carlino is BYU's all-time current leader in assists per game. As in, all-time. As in, there has never been a point guard at BYU that has more assists per game than Carlino. But yeah, we want to take the ball out of his hands because the other guy is tall. :whistle: Also, Carlino is our best perimeter defender, and that isn't close as well (though Bartley and a healthy Winder do make good additions to the defensive backcourt.) I think KC at the 3 with Haws at the 2 is perfect. I also like KC at the 4 for smaller lineups, or just to throw in some small ball to run up and down the court.
I think KC is perfect at the 3, as he adds some good defense and slashing ability, but he needs to stop shooting the 3. At least until defenders leave him so far open because of his driving that they dare him to shoot it and he has time to go through his rhytm (a la Matt Montague's junior and senior years).
Not sure you said much different than I meant. I'm not saying KC should be the 1. But Rose has and will use him to bring the ball up, initiate plays, get to the rim and dish, and yes, dish to Carlino coming off a screen. MCs APG will go down this year, for those two reasons. And I'm not sure I agree that MC is the best perimeter defender. He struggled at times last year with faster guards. Healthy Winder is better, IMO. Not bashing on MC at all. He will have a great year, and maybe as good or better than TyHaws. MC had to shoulder most ball handling last year. Now there are options with KC and that will help MCs game.
The difference between what you and I are saying is that you were suggesting that Greg Poppovich should have Khawi Leonard be the point guard instead of Parker sometimes, (based on matchups) because Leonard can handle the ball well enough not under pressure and passes well for a 6'6" small forward, and tony is so good at scoring and running around. What I am saying, is that is a silly suggestion.
Think of it more like this: Ginobili will run the point for the spurs a lot of times when Parker is out.
Not because he is better, or the matchups are better, but because Parker needs a rest and Ginobili is the next best option to bring the ball safely down the court and facilitate the offense.
What it looks like to me (based on their early season games) is that KC is Carlino's backup. I don't think that KC will ever be consistently bringing the ball down when Carlino is in, for a couple reasons that I mentioned. (Carlino is a much better passer, he is faster and gets out in open space better, and his defense is better - currently ranked #3 in steals per game for BYU's all-time). Also, Carlino's assists per game is not going to go down this year, it will go up (even though it is pretty darn high already). I will put a burger on it. The run offense is going to be BYU's bread and butter, and it is where Carlino is best suited. Think: young Steve Nash on the D'Antoni Suns, but a lot better man defense. That is BYU's future, and I hope they reach that potential this year. I like the way that all the new guys are going to fit into that.
I think that the plan is to have Carlino, Winder/Bartley all as outlet options and KC, Haws and Mika running the floor. I think that has the potential to run teams out of the gym. KC needs to work on free throws, slashing and finishing at the rim, and right now shouldn't even consider playing point or shooting jump shots.